How Soup Requests Work
Updated November 15, 2026
Sometimes a friend asks for your soup and there is nothing on their shelf you fancy. Or you know exactly what you want: the chili verde they brought to the potluck last winter.
That is what a soup request is for. You ask your friend to make something, and the trade waits until they do.
When you can make a request
A request is always the return side of a trade. It works like this:
- Ben asks for two portions of Ann’s soup.
- Ann opens the trade to pick her two portions in return.
- Instead of picking from Ben’s shelf, Ann asks Ben to make something.
You can’t start a trade by asking for a soup that isn’t on anyone’s shelf. A friend has to ask for your soup first. For the basics of that, see how a soup trade works.
How to ask
When you are choosing your return, ask your friend to make something:
- Type the soup’s name, such as Chili Verde.
- Say how many portions you would like.
The request can be part of your return or all of it. If Ben asked for three portions, Ann could pick one portion from his shelf and request two of chili verde. The numbers still have to match: three for three.
What happens while you wait
A trade with a request in it has no time limit while the soup is being made. Nobody has to cook on a deadline.
In the meantime:
- The portions Ben asked for stay held for him.
- Either person can leave a note on the trade, such as “Making it this weekend.”
- Either person can cancel with Cancel this trade. The held portions go back on the shelves.
When the soup is made
When the pot is cooked and portioned, Ben opens the trade and taps It’s ready. He then does one of two things:
- Adds it as a new soup, with a name and a few words about it.
- Picks a soup already in his kitchen, if he has made this one before.
Those portions go straight into the trade. They don’t sit on the shelf where someone else could ask for them first.
Then it is a normal trade
Once every soup in the trade exists, the trade is set. From there you have 14 days to hand the soup over in person, and either of you taps We swapped! when it is done.
If you are the one being asked
A request is a compliment. Someone wants your cooking badly enough to wait for it.
A few friendly habits:
- Leave a note saying roughly when you plan to cook.
- If you can’t make it after all, cancel the trade so your friend gets their portions back.
- Portion the soup to match the size your friend is giving you.
What a request is not
There is no board where you post a wish for anyone to answer. A request goes to one friend, inside one trade. If you are wondering what happens when a friend is slow to reply, see what if nobody answers my request.